|
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search!
I sometimes depend on logic's bounce feature for final mixes so I was
horrified that people thought there was sound degradation. Because of
Logic's klugy features, flaky bugs and e-magic's egregious support and
attitude towards its customers, I often think we're using a toy where a
professional tool is needed. But since I depend on Logic's feature set, I
decided I'd better get my own answers on the bounce issue.
I got some time in my studio yesterday and performed the following test: On
my LAP 3.7.2 (I'm still waiting for the #@!$#%&*# manual to upgrade to
4)
with Pro Tools mix hardware I digitally recorded tracks from a CD into a
session. I bounced the "mix" which was just the recorded audio
from the CD
onto a split stereo file. Adding the stereo file back to the arrange
window, I was surprised to hear a phase cancellation (not total silence)
that made the sound very thin. Needless to say, inverting phase didn't
help. After trying the same test in Pro Tools with perfect results
(inverted phase had total cancellation) I thought maybe there's just an
offset in Logic. Sure enough I went into the Sample Edit window, moved the
bounced audio by 6 samples and voila- the tracks canceled.
Conclusions:
1. The bounce feature itself does not alter audio (objectively)
2. Bounced tracks can be delayed (6 samples in my case) which can lead to
phasing effects in this test
Now can we get back to more productive topics like importuning e-magic for
the manual?
Craig Boyce
Snowbound Productions
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! © 1994-2008, All Rights Reserved. |