|
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search!
<snip>
> I guess the big question is where I, as a recording musician
> interested primarily in the songs themselves, not aspiring to be an
> audio engineer of any kind, should draw the line, in terms of
> trying to persue perfection from an engineering standpoint.
>
> Frankly, I think there is too much emphasis on the production
> quality of music these days anyway. I would like to hear a lot more
> music with second rate audio quality and the highest levels of
> originality, soul and character. <snip> I need to figure out
> what's realistic for me and my budget and know when to stop
> worrying about it.
Ben
let your ears, and even more your heart and your spirit (seriously),
guide you
I think you are on exactly the right track
keep your focus on the soul of the music
consider the sound improved if it grabs you by the guts more
and degraded if it somehow loses some of its edge, immediacy, feel
for me, on a lot of tracks, there is a sweet spot in applying master
stage limiting where detail is brought up, where transients squashed
have a slightly more explosive character, where the sense of
aliveness, dynamism is optimized
beyond that and you enter the 'bag of wool' zone - nothing is
differentiated, everything is maxed
fatiguing to listen to
something has been lost
below that things can feel thin, anemic, especially by comparison to
ALL of the music being squeezed out today by major and most
independent labels
find your own sweet spot - where the MUSICALITY is maximized - and
trust it
I also think that you are right that there is a significant
difference between how we hear music live - our ears search and find
detail, bring it up, attenuate transients (effectively compress/limit
psycho-acoustically) - and how we hear it recorded, in a 'home
listening' setting - our ears are much more passive - we expect that
C/L done for us - we don't automatically hunt and peck and squash -
that feels like too much of an effort, we are almost offended to be
asked to make it
I use VW2 plenty
it can be useful and effective in many applications
and counter-indicated in others
again, trust your ears
I agree with the advice to feed it less level
let your highest peaks going in be -3dB max
but again trust yourself
you seem to have a balanced attitude
and your priorities are better in place than most pros I know
enjoy your freedom to keep the music music
good luck
--
Rolf Pechukas
Bulk Dump Sound
Leverett, MA
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! © 1994-2008, All Rights Reserved. |