|
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search!
Thanks for all the thoughts on mastering. I fully understand that the
loudness war is a destructive thing. I was into hi-fi for a while, and so I
understand that dynamic range is basically a good thing, but there are a
couple of reasons why I care about the comparison of my tracks to commercial
ones. First, I know from my own experience that a lower volume can have a
negative affect on a listener's perception of a track, and I even think
that, to some degree, compression (however it is achieved) can,
paradoxically, make a track seem more dynamic. I think there's something
hard to define about the way aural perception of direct live sound compares
to what we hear through a bunch of electronics picking up and recording
those sounds. I think a certain amount of compression makes up for something
that's lost along the way. Maybe that's even more true when you have
modestly priced digital equipment like I do. On the other hand, I am
generally in favor of leaving the dynamics in tact, especially since some of
my tracks have parts that I want to explode by comparison to others other
parts. Hard to have that feeling when everything is limited to the max.
I guess the big question is where I, as a recording musician interested
primarily in the songs themselves, not aspiring to be an audio engineer of
any kind, should draw the line, in terms of trying to persue perfection from
an engineering standpoint.
Frankly, I think there is too much emphasis on the production quality of
music these days anyway. I would like to hear a lot more music with second
rate audio quality and the highest levels of originality, soul and
character. Who would claim that Pet Sounds is the pinnacle of audio
engineering artistry? No one, but it's a thousand times better than most of
the slick, professionally produced stuff being put out today. There's
nothing wrong with excellence in production quality, but it shouldn't be
perceived as a prerequisite for good music either, and I'm afraid it very
much is. I need to figure out what's realistic for me and my budget and know
when to stop worrying about it.
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! © 1994-2008, All Rights Reserved. |