|
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search!
Hi Hendrik
> Woh... I don't think my 'expertise' stretches that far. My
> guess would be that it's "obvious" that Logic dithers to 24
> bit, but that's just based on... well, nothing much really
> :). My intuition would say something like: if you use an I/O
> plug-in, the external gear surely gets the audio delivered in
> a useable format (I hope), which means 24 or 16 bit.
Well Logic certainly 'delivers' audio in a usable format (16 or 24bit fixed
point), I have no problem with that. The issue I was trying to get to the
bottom of is 'how' it gets to that final format. ie. if all it's internal
processing is at 32bit float, how does it convert to a lower, usable, fixed
bit depth? My concern is that the mixer simply truncates at the output
stage, unless one specifically adds dither as the final process in the
mixer. Common sense would seem to me to suggest that all outputs should be
dithered by default because, as you rightly point out, no hardware (ok I'm
generalizing) can work with 32bit float files, and therefore bit depth will
always have to be reduced as audio leaves the host environment. My concern
is that this does not necessarily take place.
I think I'm right in saying that ProTools offers a choice of either a
dithered or undithered mixer, which seems to make sense, and is certainly
what the pro market it's aimed at would and should demand. IMHO Logic
should also be offering this same functionality. Indeed it may already
dither all signals by default, I just can't find out whether it does or not.
If it doesn't, then I would choose to add dither manually to every output
bus, but I don't want to do this if it's already being done discretely, for
obvious reasons.
So many of us are insistent upon using the best converters, the highest
resolution plugins, the highest bit depth and sample rate etc. and yet this
issue rarely seems to surface. I guess many people are now mixing entirely
in-the-box, but a lot still use mixers and/or 'real' outboard of one kind or
another, and I would have thought this was fairly fundamental.
Oh well, maybe a passing developer might like to shine some light and put us
out of our misery!!
Jules
Forum Index | Read LUG: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! © 1994-2008, All Rights Reserved. |