|
Forum Index | Read EXS: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search!
I'm so confused: How can this be legal?
Shmoe
> I just received my Flossmode Studios sample discs of the Triton,
> MOTIF ES, and the Fantom X! These sounds are amazing! I've tried
> them with the EXS24 in Logic Pro 7 but it seems I have to adjust
> the release on some of them. However, when I converted them for
> Machfive the release times were better and actually easier for me
> to edit since I'm more familiar with it. However, can anyone help
> with info on shortning release times with the EXS24?
> I'm so confused: How can this be legal?
There's the rub - technically it is not... it is, in fact, totally illegal
and in most courts or law across the world could be prosecuted under various
copyright laws and laws relating to 'unfair trading'.
It's the audio equivalent of of taking images from the latest movie
blockbuster (say 'Narnia' or 'Harry Potter 4') and running off T-shirts to
sell at a car boot sale (or, indeed, on a website). It is also pretty much
the equivalent of copying/sampling any of the major sound libs (Garritan,
VSL, East-West, whatever) and selling those as 'your own'.
Think about it for a moment: Korg, Yamaha, Roland - whoever - spend $1.5
millions developing a new product (including teams of sound designers across
the world making new sounds for it). The product price is set according to
projected sales in order to recoup those substantial R+D investments. It
goes into production and hits the streets. And then some twat like this come
along, samples all the sounds and sells 'em for peanuts. Not only that, this
one brags that you don't need to spend $2,500 on the original keyboard;
$14.99 will get you the lot!! Hmmmmm!
To be honest, I believe that promoting this Floss product here is
contravening the fine and upstanding policy regarding piracy that this forum
upholds. Think about it for a moment: I doubt anyone would report user/tech
problems regarding any 3rd-party sound lib (such as the aforementioned
Garritan, VSL, East-West, whatever) that had been similarly ripped off. In
fact, I doubt the message would even make it up for public consumption...
the rigorous moderator would censor it! It's no different.
Furthermore, many of these companies have teams of legal eagles looking out
for such contraventions - Floss could be in serious trouble if/when found
out. He could be slammed with (at the very least) 'cease and desist' orders
from the company's attorneys, could be charged for copyright convention of
their sounds, for using (even *abusing*) their registered trademark, etc..
I am sure the guy is acting in all innocence but what he is doing is
technically illegal. Technically as well, anyone who subscribes to his
products by buying them is complicit in an act of piracy of intellectual
copyright.
Best regards,
Steve
http://www.hollowsun.com
--- In exs-users@yahoogroups.com, Hollow Sun <steve@h...> wrote:
>
> I am sure the guy is acting in all innocence but what he is doing is
> technically illegal. Technically as well, anyone who subscribes to his
> products by buying them is complicit in an act of piracy of
intellectual
> copyright.
> Best regards,
> Steve
> http://www.hollowsun.com
Thanks for this, Steve. Until we can clarify that these sample
libraries are absolutely bona fide, in accordance with our long
standing list policy, we will not accept any further posts praising or
advising people to buy them. Offering them under the names of current
synthesizer products from major MI manufacturers certainly seems
dubious.
thanks and regards
Mark - LUG Admin
Hi,
when clicking on the E button in the "zone" window the
sample editor opens and it is possible to edit the
loop points etc graphically. The values from the zone
window are read into the sample editor window and when
dragging the LS and LE points the values are updated
in the zone display of EXS.
This works at times, but at other times the changes
that I do in the graphic display ar NOT reflected in
the EXS zone window. Is there something that I have to
"activate"?
Logic Pro 7.1.1
Cheers and thanks in advance
JF
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"It is forbidden to kill; therefore all murderers are punished unless
they kill in large numbers and to the sound of trumpets."
Voltaire (1694-1778)
Dear Logic-Users,
I am very concerned about the implications on my company reputation as one
of your posts is appearing as "number 3" and "number 4"
in Google Search results when a customer searches for our domain name. It
includes very misleading information which could have a negative impact on
our company and brand. Here is the link to this post:
http://logic-users.org/forums/EXS/thread/4894
And here is the impact it is having on Google...
http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=www.inspirationsounds.co.uk&m
eta=
I totally understand that the views expressed are not your own, and that
this is a forum, however, I am requesting that you (as the moderator of the
site) remove any pages that refer to us acting in any type of "illegal
activity". We have never sold illegal products, and we would never do
this. We are a legitimate Sample CD retailer (and developer). We buy our
products from Time+Space, Loopmasters, AMG, etc... Thirdly, we are major
contributors to the "Anti-Piracy" forums that are being set up to
counteract Piracy on torrent sites. I would be happy for you to contact any
of the above suppliers to confirm that we are a 100% legitimate retailer of
Sample CDs. If you ask them what Jan Franklin's attitude to illegal
downloads of Sample CDs is.. You will get a VERY strong reaction. We are
systematically going through all of the major developers urging them to take
ACTION against illegal sites and individuals who are destroying the
industry.
For a short while we did sell some Synthesizer Patch sample cds, however,
these did not include the original patches from the original synthesizers
and therefore, this was not unlawful. They were simply recordings of fresh
"non-factory" presets, very much like developers of new synth
sound banks make money from selling patches for the Access Virus, etc. One
of your users states:
"it is, in fact, totally illegal and in most courts or law across the
world could be prosecuted under various copyright laws and laws relating to
'unfair trading' "
I don't appreciate this. I also think the way that our company name
(Inspiration Sounds) seems to be linked with www.flossmodestudios.com is
also misleading. We have nothing to do with this company and we have no
associations with them. I have sent this email to your "WHOIS"
lookup email address, but I thought I would also post it here so your users
no our stance on this matter. I look forward to hearing your thoughts on
this.
Kind regards,
Jan Franklin (Owner - Inspiration Sounds)
WWW.INSPIRATIONSOUNDS.CO.UK
*********************************************************************
Jan Franklin: General Manager / Owner Inspiration Sounds
Address: 90 Dorchester Road, Lodmoor, Weymouth, Dorset, DT4 7LD, UK
Direct No: +44 (0)1305 839 273
Main Line: +44 (0)8450 943 077
Email: info@inspirationsounds.co.uk
Main Website: http://www.inspirationsounds.co.uk
Forum Index | Read EXS: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! Forum Index | Read EXS: Policy/Rules Messages Threads Digests | Post New Message | Search! © 1994-2008, All Rights Reserved. |